How to Navigate Applying for a Job in the Current Market

The job market is tough right now. Layoffs and economic uncertainty have made it more competitive than ever—especially in the nonprofit world. I’ve seen incredible candidates apply for dozens of roles without much traction - not because they aren’t qualified, but because there are more people chasing fewer positions and applicants haven’t adjusted their approach to meet the moment.

If you’re on the job hunt, here are three key ways to strengthen your strategy and stand out from the crowd:

1. Customize Your Application for Each Role and Organization

One of the biggest mistakes job seekers make is sending out the same resume and cover letter to every job opening. In a competitive market, that just doesn’t cut it—especially in mission-driven organizations, where passion and alignment matter as much as experience.

Start with your cover letter. Rather than a generic overview of your background, take the time to explain why you care about their mission. Share a personal story, experience, or value that connects to their work. Then, highlight two or three key strengths that match what they’re looking for in the role. This shows you’ve done your research and that you’re not just applying to 100 places—you’re genuinely interested in this one.

When they ask you, “Why are you applying?”—don’t lead with the fact that you were laid off or are exploring options because of uncertainty in your current role. That might be true, but it’s not your strongest message. Instead, focus on what draws you to this organization and this opportunity. That’s what makes you stand out.

Your resume should be just as targeted. Use language from the job description and prioritize your most relevant experiences and accomplishments. Think of it like answering this unspoken question: “Can you do this job, and have you done something similar before?”

Finally, take the time to create multiple inroads. Before and after you apply, reach out to people at the organization—current employees, a hiring manager, or even someone in a similar role. A quick, thoughtful message on LinkedIn expressing your interest can go a long way. Just getting your name mentioned inside the organization through a warm contact can go a long way.

2. Be Open to In-Person or Hybrid Roles

It’s no secret that many job seekers are still hoping for fully remote roles. And while remote work isn’t disappearing entirely, many nonprofits are now shifting back to in-person or hybrid models—often requiring two or three days a week in the office. That shift reflects a desire for stronger team culture, collaboration, and real-time connection that’s harder to replicate over Zoom.

If you’ve set a hard line on remote work only, you may unintentionally be ruling out some of the most compelling opportunities—roles that offer strong missions, great teams, or better compensation.

Think about your priorities. If you find a position and mission that inspires you, offers growth potential, and meets your salary expectations, be willing to flex on the format. Even hybrid schedules that require some office time can provide the work-life balance many people still crave, while helping you stay connected to your colleagues in meaningful ways.

And from the employer’s perspective, being open to hybrid or in-person work demonstrates flexibility, commitment, and a desire to be part of the team in a deeper way. That mindset alone can give you a competitive edge.

3. Clearly Communicate Your Transferable Skills

Many people currently on the job market haven’t had to interview in years—or they’re coming from different sectors, such as government, corporate, or education. If that’s you, be prepared for hiring managers to question whether your background is the right fit.

That’s not a dealbreaker—but it is something you need to be proactive about.

Use your application materials to connect the dots. If you haven’t done the exact role before, show how your past work demonstrates the same skills, responsibilities, or results. Translate your experience into the language of the new sector or role.

And then prepare for interviews where you’ll have to do this in real time. Practice with a friend or colleague—not just answering “Why should we hire you?” but responding to targeted questions about skills they may think you’re missing. For example:

• “You’ve never worked in fundraising before. How would you approach donor engagement?”
• “You’re coming from the public sector—how would you adjust to a less structured environment?”
• “This role involves team leadership, but your resume doesn’t show direct supervisory experience. Can you speak to that?”

Don’t wait for those questions to trip you up. Anticipate them. Prepare clear, confident responses that bridge the gap between your past experience and their current needs.

Final Thought

In a market this crowded, it’s not enough to meet the minimum qualifications. You have to show that you’re intentional, flexible, and ready to hit the ground running. Customize your application to the organization, be open to different work formats, and proactively address potential gaps in your experience.

Getting hired isn’t about applying to more jobs—it’s about applying smarter and demonstrating your genuine belief that you are the perfect fit for this specific organization and role.

‍